Dave Meltzer Ratings Wrestlemania 40 28

Alright, my wrestling-loving comrades, gather 'round! We’ve just survived the epic, the monumental, the absolutely bonkers Wrestlemania 40! And you know what that means, right? It means it’s time for the main event… of the internet! Yep, we’re talking about the man, the myth, the legend (or at least the guy who’s seen more wrestling matches than anyone alive), Dave Meltzer, and his much-anticipated Wrestlemania 40 ratings!

Now, before we dive headfirst into the star-studded pool of Meltzer’s scores, let’s just take a moment to appreciate the sheer magnitude of Wrestlemania 40. Two nights of pure, unadulterated wrestling goodness. We had surprises, we had shocks, we had matches that made us jump out of our seats and maybe spill our popcorn (oops!). It was, dare I say it, a pretty darn good show. But the real question on everyone’s mind is: did Dave agree?

For those living under a rock (or, you know, just not glued to wrestling forums 24/7), Dave Meltzer is the wrestling journalist equivalent of a Michelin inspector. He’s been watching, critiquing, and rating matches for decades, and his star ratings are the golden ticket for many fans trying to figure out if a match was truly a classic or just a fun little romp. Think of him as the highly opinionated, incredibly knowledgeable friend who always has something to say about the wrestling.

So, let’s break it down, shall we? We’re going to go through some of the biggest matches from Wrestlemania 40 and see what the maestro himself had to say. And remember, these are just ratings, people! Wrestling is an art form, and art is subjective. What might be a five-star masterpiece to one person could be a… well, a three-star solid effort to another. No shade, just appreciation for the different tastes out there!

Night One: The Kickoff to Chaos!

Night one of Wrestlemania 40? Phew! It was a marathon of mayhem, and I’m still recovering. My voice is a little hoarse from yelling at the TV, and I’m pretty sure my dog is judging my life choices. But hey, it was worth it! And so, let’s see how Dave rated the battles that kicked off this year's spectacular.

The Women's Tag Team Showcase: A Star is Born (and Reborn!)

We kicked things off with a bang! The Fatal 4-Way for the Women's Tag Team Championships. Now, this was a match with a lot of moving parts, a lot of talent, and a whole lot of potential. These ladies came out swinging, and it was clear they wanted to make a statement. You had the powerhouse pairings, the technical wizards, and the pure adrenaline junkies. It was a fantastic way to get the crowd fired up.

And Dave? Well, he seemed to be a fan too! He gave this one a solid 3.75 stars. Not too shabby for an opener! It’s a great sign when the opening match gets the crowd invested and earns a respectable score. It shows that the women’s division is absolutely on fire and continues to deliver the goods. Seriously, if you missed it, go back and watch! It’s a testament to the hard work and dedication of these incredible athletes.

The Undisputed WWE Universal Championship: A Grudge Match for the Ages!

Okay, this was the one. The match that had everyone talking for months. Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes. The Bloodline saga reaching its crescendo. The emotional weight of this match was heavier than a sumo wrestler on a treadmill. Cody’s quest to finish his story, Roman’s seemingly unbreakable reign… it was all on the line.

This match wasn't just about holds and slams; it was about storytelling. The drama, the near falls, the interference (oh, the interference!), it was all part of the unfolding epic. You could feel the energy in the arena, and I’m sure many of us at home were on the edge of our seats, biting our nails down to the quick.

So, what did Dave think of this monumental clash? He awarded it a whopping 4.25 stars! You know, for a match with so much pressure and so much riding on it, that’s a seriously impressive score. It shows that while the story was king, the wrestling itself was also top-notch. It was a fitting main event for Night One, delivering on almost every promise. And Cody, man, Cody… he did it!

The Intercontinental Championship: A Showcase of Speed and Skill!

Next up, we had Sami Zayn challenging Gunther for the Intercontinental Championship. This was a match I was personally very excited about. Gunther, the Ring General, the man who’s held that title for what feels like an eternity, against the ever-popular, never-give-up Sami Zayn. This was a clash of styles, a battle of heart versus sheer dominance.

Sami’s underdog spirit is something special, and Gunther’s relentless power is equally captivating. You knew this was going to be a hard-hitting, back-and-forth affair. It was the kind of match where you winced with every chop and cheered with every comeback.

And the verdict from Dave? He gave this one a brilliant 4.25 stars as well! See? Another incredible performance that got the high praise. It’s a testament to how good Sami Zayn is, and honestly, how consistently great Gunther has been as champion. This match was pure wrestling magic. Chef’s kiss!

Night Two: The Grand Finale of Glory!

Night two! The final stretch! The last chance for some wrestlers to etch their names in Wrestlemania history. The energy was palpable, the stakes were higher, and the anticipation was a tangible thing. My snacks were running low, but my excitement was at an all-time high. Let’s see how the second night stacked up!

The World Heavyweight Championship: A Clash of Titans!

We had Damian Priest cashing in his Money in the Bank on Drew McIntyre, setting up this encounter for the World Heavyweight Championship. This was a physical, hard-hitting affair that showcased the power and intensity of both men. Drew, looking absolutely shredded and ready for war, versus Priest, who’d been lurking, waiting for his moment.

This match had a lot of intensity, a lot of raw power on display. You could see the effort and the struggle in every move. It was the kind of match that makes you appreciate the sheer athleticism and toughness of these guys.

Dave’s take on this one? He awarded it 3.75 stars. A solid rating for a solid, hard-fought championship match. It might not have reached the stratospheric heights of some of the other bouts, but it was a good, competitive contest that kept the crowd engaged. And hey, Priest is finally a world champion! That’s a big deal!

The United States Championship: A High-Flying Spectacle!

Logan Paul vs. Kevin Owens vs. Randy Orton for the United States Championship! Talk about a wildcard! Logan Paul, the YouTuber turned wrestling phenomenon, facing off against two absolute legends of the game. This match was guaranteed to be unpredictable, chaotic, and probably involve some ridiculous spots.

And boy, did it deliver! We had high-flying maneuvers, some surprisingly good wrestling from Logan, and the usual Orton brilliance. The crowd was electric for this one, especially for Orton. It was a true spectacle, a showcase of different wrestling styles colliding.

Dave’s rating for this triple threat thriller? A respectable 3.5 stars. It was a fun, entertaining match that delivered on the spectacle. While maybe not a technical masterpiece, it was a very enjoyable ride, and that’s what matters for a match like this. Logan Paul continues to surprise people, that’s for sure!

The Women's World Championship: A Showstopper Performance!

Rhea Ripley vs. Becky Lynch! This was another marquee match, a clash of two absolute powerhouses in the women’s division. Rhea, the dominant champion, against Becky, the fighting spirit personified. This match had intensity, it had grit, and it had two incredible performers leaving it all in the ring.

You could feel the history and the rivalry in this one. Rhea’s sheer strength and presence against Becky’s resilience and determination. It was a battle that had the crowd captivated from start to finish.

Dave’s rating for this epic encounter? A fantastic 4.25 stars! Wow! That’s a huge compliment for both women, especially for Rhea who has been on an absolute tear as champion. This match was a prime example of how far the women’s division has come and the incredible talent it boasts. Simply outstanding!

The Rock & Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes & Seth Rollins: A Tag Team Tussle for the Ages!

Okay, this was the moment none of us saw coming, or maybe some of us did, but it was still WILD! The Rock and Roman Reigns teaming up against Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins. This was more than just a tag match; it was a spectacle, a historical moment, a clash of eras. The electricity in the arena was insane. Every time The Rock or Roman did anything, the crowd went absolutely bonkers.

The dynamic of The Rock and Roman together was something special to witness. The charisma, the arrogance, the sheer star power! Cody and Seth, fighting the good fight, representing the future. It was a chaotic, fun, and absolutely memorable match that set the stage for the main event perfectly.

Dave’s rating? He gave this one a very solid 4.5 stars! That’s seriously high praise, and honestly, it’s hard to argue. This match was pure entertainment. It had everything you want in a big Wrestlemania spectacle: star power, drama, surprises, and a whole lot of fun. It was a moment that will be replayed for years to come.

The Undisputed WWE Universal Championship Rematch: The End of an Era (or the Beginning of a New One?)

And then, the main event of Night Two. Cody Rhodes vs. Roman Reigns. The rematch. The culmination of Cody’s journey. The weight of the world, or at least the wrestling world, was on this match. This was it. The moment of truth. Would Cody finish his story? Would Roman’s reign continue? The tension was thicker than molasses in January.

This match was a rollercoaster of emotions. The physicality, the storytelling, the sheer willpower on display. Every near fall had us on the edge of our seats. The Bloodline’s involvement, the unexpected turns, it was all part of the epic conclusion to this chapter.

Dave’s final, and arguably most important, rating of Wrestlemania 40? He gave this match a phenomenal 5 stars! Yes, you read that right. A perfect five stars! This is the ultimate accolade, the highest praise. It means Dave felt this match was a true masterpiece, a classic that will be remembered for generations. And honestly, seeing Cody finally achieve his dream, after all the heartache and struggle, it felt earned. It felt like a perfect ending to a perfect story.

The Overall Impression: A Wrestlemania for the Books!

So, there you have it, folks! The Meltzer ratings for Wrestlemania 40. We saw some absolute bangers, some incredible storytelling, and a main event that, by Dave’s count, reached perfection. It’s clear that Wrestlemania 40 was a resounding success, a testament to the talent and dedication of everyone involved.

It’s always fun to see how the wrestling world reacts, and Dave Meltzer’s ratings are always a big part of that conversation. But remember, these are just numbers. The real magic of wrestling lies in the emotions it evokes, the stories it tells, and the shared experience it creates for us as fans.

Wrestlemania 40 delivered on so many levels. It gave us moments we’ll be talking about for years, it crowned new champions, and it provided us with pure, unadulterated entertainment. And that, my friends, is what wrestling is all about. So, even if your favorite match didn't get a perfect score, take a moment to appreciate the incredible spectacle we witnessed. We’re part of something special, and Wrestlemania 40 just reminded us of that. Here's to another year of incredible wrestling and more moments that make us jump, cheer, and maybe even shed a tear of joy! Keep on wrestling, everyone!